|Year : 2020 | Volume
| Issue : 3 | Page : 105-108
Factors affecting outcomes of surgically treated patients with cranial extradural hematoma: A cross-sectional study
Ghazwan A Lafta1, Ali A Dolachee2, Alyaa K Al-Zubaidi3
1 Department of Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, University of Al-Ameed, Iraq
2 Department of Surgery, College of Medicine, University of Al-Qadisiyah, Iraq
3 Ministry of Health, Baghdad, Iraq
|Date of Submission||19-Dec-2019|
|Date of Decision||20-Apr-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||29-Apr-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||11-May-2020|
Ghazwan A Lafta
Department of Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, University of Al-Ameed, Iraq
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Objective: To evaluate the factors resulting in the poor outcomes in patients with extradural hematoma (EDH).
Methods: The study was conducted at the Neurosurgery Teaching Hospital in Baghdad with a group of 100 surgically treated EDH patients and was carried prospectively from February 1st, 2015 to May 1st, 2017. The baseline information (gender, age, cause of injury, time interval between injury and reception, Glasgow coma scale, etc.) of the patients was recorded, and the variables affecting the outcomes were analyzed.
Results: In the study, 80% of patients were male; 54% were between 10-29 years old; the commonest cause of injury was fall accounting for 51%; 78% of the patients got good functional recovery, and 10% had a residual disability; 12% died. Better functional recovery was found among patients with a shorter time interval (≤3 h) (P=0.001), while the longer time interval (>3 h) increased the residual disability (P=0.005). In addition, functional recovery increased six times with higher Glasgow coma scale (P=0.001), and inversely related to mortality (P=0.005).
Conclusions: Age between 10 and 29 years, male gender, and depth of hematoma more than 5 cm are at higher risks of poor outcomes of patients with surgically treated EDH. Neurological conditions on admission and time interval between injury and reception are also important factors.
Keywords: Extradural hematoma; Glasgow coma scale; Head injury; Outcome
|How to cite this article:|
Lafta GA, Dolachee AA, Al-Zubaidi AK. Factors affecting outcomes of surgically treated patients with cranial extradural hematoma: A cross-sectional study. J Acute Dis 2020;9:105-8
|How to cite this URL:|
Lafta GA, Dolachee AA, Al-Zubaidi AK. Factors affecting outcomes of surgically treated patients with cranial extradural hematoma: A cross-sectional study. J Acute Dis [serial online] 2020 [cited 2022 Oct 2];9:105-8. Available from: https://www.jadweb.org/text.asp?2020/9/3/105/283887
| 1. Introduction|| |
Extradural hematoma (EDH), a blood accumulation between the dura matter and the skull’s inner table, is an infrequent sequela of head injury. It occurs in less than 2% of the patients admitted with craniocerebral trauma and in up to 15% of fatal head injuries. In 85%-95% of the patients, EDH is associated with an overlying skull fracture. Blood vessels closed to the fracture are the usual sources of the bleeding forming EDH,.
When the hematoma is deeper than 1 cm or larger than 25 mL, EDH is usually clinically significant. It is reported that the hemorrhage volume is at least 100 mL in death cases,,.
Associated intracranial lesions such as subdural hematoma, intracerebral hematoma, and cerebral contusion result in an increased mortality rate,. Other factors affecting the outcomes and prognosis include increased age, poor neurological condition according to the Glasgow coma scale (GCS), large hematoma volume, delay in an operative evacuation, large midline shift, and postoperative elevation in intracranial pressure,. Glasgow outcome scale (GOS) is widely accepted as a standard method to assess the outcomes of the patients with head trauma. Our study aims to evaluate the risk factors of poor outcomes of EDH patients in the middle and south of Iraq.
| 2. Materials and methods|| |
2.1. Ethical approval
This study was approved by the local Ethical Committee in the Neurosurgery Department of the Neurosurgery Teaching Hospital in Baghdad (291 on 30/1/2018).
It was a cross-sectional study conducted at the Neurosurgery Teaching Hospital in Baghdad and was carried prospectively from February 1st, 2015 to May 1st, 2017.
One hundred patients with head injury and surgically treated EDH had been selected and included in this study after taking oral and written consent. They were transferred from the middle and south of Iraq, and categorized according to the age, gender, occupation, initial GCS, the chief complaint at presentation, the consciousness throughout the course of the hematoma, physical signs at presentation, type of injury, the time interval between injury and reception, the time between reception and surgery, site (frontal, parietal, etc.), thickness, side of hematoma, radiological finding apart from EDH, surgical procedure, associated injuries, intraoperative findings, source of bleeding, and outcomes.
All the patients had been received at the emergency department where they were fully evaluated. Then, GCS was adopted for an initial assessment in all of the patients. This scale can measure the severity of the injury, and patients with GCS from 13-15 are considered with mild injury, 9-12 with moderate injury, and 3-8 with severe injury. The patients with GCS less than 8 were transferred to the ICU for specific resuscitation. A full history was taken either from the patients or from their relatives in cases of loss of consciousness or the presence of amnesia. A full neurological examination was performed for each patient. Brain CT scans were done as the radiological investigation of choice for all of the patients. Definitive management was done for all patients including craniotomy and craniectomy.
The follow-up was done at 1st month, 3rd months, 6th months after discharge through regular visits.
2.3. Statistical analysis
Statistical analysis was performed by SPSS version 17. Categorical data were expressed as percentage. Chi-square was used to analyze categorical data. Regression models were used to determine which variable independently affects functional recovery, disability, and mortality. The significant level of the test was expressed at α=0.05.
| 3. Results|| |
A total of 100 cases of EDH (80% males and 20% females) were included in this study, among which 19% cases were ≤9 years old, 54% cases between 10-29 years old, 25% cases between 30-59 years old, and 2% patients >60. The causes of injury were different, with fall from height accounting for 51%, road traffic accidents for 37%, and assault injuries for 12%. A total of 46% of patients had the time interval between injury and reception less than 3 h, while 54% had more than 3 h. The patients arrived at the emergency room with different conscious conditions, of whom 19% had GCS of 3-8, and 43% had GCS of 9-12, while 38% had GCS of 13-15.
Altogether, 26% of the patients complained of headache and vomiting, and 9% had convulsions. On examination, there were 23 patients had ear bleeding, 20 with scalp wounds, 15 with subgaleal hematoma, and 15 with epistaxis. There were 3 hemiplegic patients, 13 cases of hemiparesis, 8 cases of facial palsy, and 6 cases with olfactory nerve palsy. In addition, 30 patients were with unilateral pupil dilation and 9 patients with bilateral dilation. CT scan was done for all patients, and the results showed that 87% of the patients had a hematoma in the thickness of 1-3 cm, while 11% had 3.5-5.0 cm in thickness. In addition, only 2% of the patients showed a hematoma more than 5 cm in thickness. There were associated intracranial lesions in some patients, as 5 of them had an acute subdural hematoma, and 3 of them had an intracerebral hemorrhage, while 2 of them with brain stem contusion. Surgery was done for all patients, and follow-up was carried out at 1 month, 3 months, 6 months after discharge through regular visits. There were 78% of the patients with good functional recovery, 10% with residual disability, and 12 % were dead.
GCS scores had affected the outcomes (P=0.01) [Table 1]. When GCS (3-8) changed to (13-15), the coefficient factor (B) was 6.18 (P=0.001) i.e. functional recovery improved by six times when GCS scores increased especially equally or higher than 13, which had no effect on the disability of the patients, but inversely related to the death (P=0.005) [Table 2]. The time interval between injury and reception also had an effect on the outcomes (P=0.02), as patients with a shorter time interval showed better functional recovery (≤3 h) (P=0.001), while the longer time interval (>3 h) increased the residual disability (P=0.005), but the time interval had no effect on the death [Table 1].
|Table 2: Effect of each studied variable on the outcomes (functional recovery, residual disability, and death) after adjustment of other independent variables|
Click here to view
| 4. Discussion|| |
Our study showed that 78% of patients had a good functional recovery, 10% had residual disability, and 12% were dead, which is similar to the study of Kiboi et al. .
Age between 10 and 29 years old (54%) was one of the risk factors of EDH in our study. Similarly, Chowdhury et al. found that 57.07% of the patients were between 11 and 30 years old. The reason may be this age group has more daily activities than the others (especially school-age). Regarding gender, 80% of the patients were males, and 20% were females. The high incidence of EDH in males is attributed to their activities. Males are more prone to trauma as they are more mobile and travel more for their day-to-day activities than females. Islam et al. also found that 92.2% of the patients were males and 7.8% were females, and Chowdhury et al. showed that 86.32 % of the patients were males and 13.78 % were females in their studies concerning EDH.
Depth of hematoma was considered as a risk factor for poor outcomes. Hematoma thickness higher than 5 cm is fatal. With the expansion of the space-occupying lesion, uncal herniation and brain stem injury will be unavoidable and consequently lead to death. This perspective was consistent with that of Rehman et al. and Satapathy et al. ,.
GCS is efficient in predicting the outcomes of EDH. In the present study, functional recovery increased six times with higher GCS, and inversely related to the mortality, but had no effect on the disability of the patients. This was attributed to the fact that GCS is an important prognostic factor to reflect the brain condition, hence it can be used to predict the probability of survival or death.
The study of Islam et al. showed that 73.5% of their patients had initial GCS of 9-15, while 26.5% had GCS of 3-8. The study of Rehman et al. showed that 54% of the patients were presented with CGS of 13-15, 26% of 9-12, 20% of 3-8. This study compared the GCS with the corresponding outcomes depending on the GOS, and they founded that GCS of 3-8 was associated with unfavorable outcomes while patients with GCS of 13-15 and 9-12 associated with favorable outcomes. Haltmeier et al. mentioned that there was a strong correlation of the outcomes of EDH with GCS. In conclusion, higher GCS scores indicate better outcomes, while lower scores imply worse outcomes.
The time interval between injury and reception also showed a great significance for EDH outcomes. Better functional recovery was found among patients with a shorter time interval (≤3 h) (P=0.001), while the longer time interval (>3 h) increased the residual disability, but the time interval had no effect on the mortality. The reason is that the shortest time can maintain the viability of brain tissue and lower the degree of brain injury, and vice versa.
Korinth et al. mentioned that delayed EDH treatment would result in a poor outcome. Royal College of Surgeons of England recommended that surgical decompression should be carried out within 4 h after the onset of significant symptoms to get good recovery. We recommend an establishment of more neurosurgery centers especially in Baghdad and at least one center in each other governorate in order to provide optimum neurosurgical care and adequate management at the initial time of injury. A proper schedule and plan of management should be well informed to the residents in emergency departments of the general hospitals and general practitioners in rural areas. For head-injured patients, a special neurological examination record form can be used for such purposes. Hard efforts should be made to shorten the time between injury and receiving the patient, as well as reaching the victims in high ways should be as quick as possible. Resuscitation and life-saving measures must be provided to the patients at the accident location and should be reviewed at the first receiving healthcare center and continue until reaching the neurosurgical center, to ensure adequate hemodynamic state to minimize the possibilities of secondary brain injuries. Safety measures should be applied during driving motorcycles including wearing helmets, to minimize head injury due to road traffic accidents as much as possible. More attention should be given to the children and closely watching their activities and decorating the houses with the safety walls around the roves and along the stairs.
| 5. Conclusion|| |
Age between 10 and 29 years, male gender and depth of hematoma more than 5 cm are at increased risk of poor outcomes in patients with surgically treated EDH. GCS on admission and time between injury and reception are important factors influencing the outcomes.
Conflict of interest statement
The authors report no conflict of interest.
G.A.L.: Corresponding author, study designer, and writing the manuscript; A.A.D.: Data collector, interpreter, and writing the introduction; A.K.A: Data analysis, writing the results.
| References|| |
Winn HR. Chapter 325. In: Youmans neurological surgery
. 6th ed.Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier; 2011, p. 3294.
Bhat AR, Kirmani AR, Wani MA. Disappearance of intracranial extradural hematomas: Role of diastatic cranial fracture and intracranial pressure-an institutional experience. Asian J Neurosurg
Pereira EL, Rodrigues DB, Lima LO, Sawada LA, Hermes Mde N Jr. Bilateral assymetric epidural hematoma. Surg Neurol Int
Magill ST, Rutledge WC, Hemphill III JC, Manley GT. Hemorrhagic mass lesions. Neurocrit Care Manag Neurosurg Patient
Bittle MM, Gunn ML, Gross JA, Stern EJ. In: Trauma radiology companion: methods, guidelines, and imaging fundamentals
. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2012, p. 34.
Araujo JL, Aguiar UP, Todeschini AB, Saade NE, Veiga JC. Epidemiological analysis of 210 cases of surgically treated traumatic extradural hematoma. Rev Col Brass Cir
Aurangzeb A, Afridi EA, Khan SA, Muhammad G, Ihsan A, Hussain I, et al. Frequency of extradural haematoma in patients with linear skull fracture. J Ayub Med Coll
Kandregula S, Sadashiva N, Konar S, Rao KN, Shukla D, Bhat D, et al. Surgical management of traumatic extradural hematomas in children: an analysis of 201 patients at a tertiary neurosurgical center. Child Nerv Syst
Houseman CM, Belverud SA, Narayan RK. Closed head injury, principles of neurological surgery. In: Ellenbogen RG, Abdulrauf SI, Sekhar LN, (eds). Prognosis after head injury
. 3rd ed. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier; 2012, p. 346.
Lu Z, Zhu G, Qiu Y, Cheng X. Minimally-invasive aspiration and drainage for management of traumatic epidural hematoma straddling transverse sinus. Neurol India
Kiboi JG, Nganga HK, Kitunguu PK, Mbuthia JM. Factors influencing the outcomes in extradural haematoma patients. Ann Afr Surg
Khaled CN, Raihan MZ, Chowdhury FH, Ashadullah AT, Sarkar MH, Hossain SS. Surgical management of traumatic extradural haematoma: Experiences with 610 patients and prospective analysis. Indian J Neurotrauma
Islam MJ, Saha SK, Elahy MF, Islam KM, Ahamed SU. Factors influencing the outcome of patients with acute extradural haematomas undergoing surgery. Bangladesh J Med Sci
Rehman L, Karachi NJ. Association of outcome of traumatic extradural hematoma with Glasgow Coma Scale and hematoma size. Ann Pak Inst Med Sci
Satapathy MC, Dash D, Mishra SS, Tripathy SR, Nath PC, Jena SP. Spectrum and outcome of traumatic brain injury in children<15 years: A tertiary level experience in India. Int J Crit Illn Inj Sci
Tjahjadi M, Arifin MZ, Gill AS, Faried A. Early mortality predictor of severe traumatic brain injury: A single center study of prognostic variables based on admission characteristics. Indian J Neurotrauma
Haltmeier T, Benjamin E, Siboni S, Dilektasli E, Inaba K, Demetriades D. Prehospital intubation for isolated severe blunt traumatic brain injury: worse outcomes and higher mortality. Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg
Korinth M, Weinzieri M, Gilsbach JM. Treatment options in traumatic extradural hematomas. Unfallchirurg
The Royal College of Surgeons of England Trauma Committee. The Royal College of Surgeons of England: A position paper on the acute management of patients with head injury. Ann R Coll Surg Engl
[Table 1], [Table 2]